12321 Fairhill Road, Cleveland, OH 44120 (MLS # 5261583)
|
Rich in architectural character and timeless elegance, this exceptional home showcases an extraordinary blend of craftsmanship, historic charm, and thoughtful updates. Distinctive details include diamond-pattern-leaded glass windows, original English white oak wide-plank floors, Gothic-inspired arched ceilings, decorative plaster crown moldings, and dramatic cathedral doorways. All original first-floor wood floors were beautifully refinished in 2020. The welcoming living room makes a stunning impression with its soaring wood-beamed ceiling, expansive wall of leaded glass windows, stone-surround fireplace, and French doors opening to the magnificent stone terrace. The formal dining room features exquisite plaster moldings and two walls of leaded glass windows. A charming first-floor reading room offers built-in bookcases, a cozy fireplace, and French doors leading to the patio. The second-floor features four bedrooms and two full baths. The spacious primary bedroom is highlighted by leaded glass windows, its own fireplace, generous closet space, and a private sunroom. The third floor provides additional versatility with a bedroom, office, studio, cedar closet and full bath. Outdoor living is equally impressive, featuring a sandstone terrace with a distinctive fountain wall, perennial gardens, and breathtaking views. Significant exterior improvements include a custom stone driveway and front exterior retaining wall, completed in 2024. Major masonry restoration was also completed to the chimney and surrounding slate roof valleys, with annual slate roof maintenance performed to preserve the integrity and longevity of this distinctive roof. Just minutes from University Circle, renowned hospitals, universities, and an easy commute to downtown Cleveland. A truly special home where historic elegance and distinctive architecture meet.
Property Type(s):
Single Family
| Last Updated | 11/19/2026 | Tract | Donald Grays Proposed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year Built | 1930 | Garage Spaces | 1.0 |
| County | Cuyahoga |
Additional Details
| AIR | Central Air |
|---|---|
| AIR CONDITIONING | Yes |
| AMENITIES | Snow Removal |
| APPLIANCES | Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator |
| BASEMENT | Unfinished, Yes |
| CONSTRUCTION | Brick, Stone |
| FIREPLACE | Yes |
| GARAGE | Yes |
| HEAT | Forced Air |
| HOA DUES | 500|Annually |
| INTERIOR | Beamed Ceilings, Bookcases, Cedar Closet(s), Chandelier, Crown Molding, Entrance Foyer |
| LOT | 3101 sq ft |
| PARKING | Attached, Garage |
| SEWER | Public Sewer |
| STORIES | 3+ |
| STYLE | Tudor |
| SUBDIVISION | Donald Grays Proposed |
| TAXES | 13745 |
| WATER | Public |
Location
Contact us about this Property
| / | |
| We respect your online privacy and will never spam you. By submitting this form with your telephone number you are consenting for Ben Schafer to contact you even if your name is on a Federal or State "Do not call List". | |
Listing provided by: Betsy Forbes | 440-954-1258, HomeSmart Real Estate Momentum LLC, betsyfsellshomes@gmail.com, 440-954-1258
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of NEOHREX. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Ben Schafer Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
Listing information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed.
Data Last Updated: 11/19/26 11:40 PM PST
This IDX solution is (c) Diverse Solutions 2026.
Like Us On Facebook

Search for your next home
Latest Real Estate
-
$44,900
Cross Street
Caldwell, OH
-
$48,000
SR 215 ST
Caldwell, OH
-
$49,000
Dudley road
Caldwell, OH
-
$64,900
16704 Terrace Avenue
Caldwell, OH
-
$115,000
Groves Hill RD
Caldwell, OH
-
$125,000
Davis Ridge
Caldwell, OH
-
$150,000
18937 Salt Run Road
Caldwell, OH
-
$159,900
1120 North Street
Caldwell, OH
-
$169,900
46601 Valley Road
Caldwell, OH
-
$174,000
45351 Kip Clark Road
Caldwell, OH
-
$199,900
44250 Fairground Road
Caldwell, OH
-
$200,000
Spence Hill Rd
Caldwell, OH
-
$225,000
Crum Ridge Rd
Caldwell, OH
-
$259,000
40277 Ashton Hill Road
Caldwell, OH
-
$286,500
Keithtown Road
Caldwell, OH
-
$356,545
40278 Forest Grove Ridge Road
Caldwell, OH
-
$425,000
Crum Ridge Rd
Caldwell, OH
-
$654,900
Brownrigg Rd
Caldwell, OH
-
$1,800,000
17030 McConnellsville Road
Caldwell, OH
Lot Size
4,400 sqft
Home Size
908 sqft
Beds
3 Beds
Baths
1 Bath
Lot Size
5,716 sqft
Home Size
1,728 sqft
Beds
4 Beds
Baths
2 Baths
Lot Size
1.33 ac
Home Size
738 sqft
Beds
3 Beds
Baths
2 Baths
Lot Size
36,225 sqft
Home Size
1,229 sqft
Beds
3 Beds
Baths
1 Bath
Lot Size
8.07 ac
Home Size
1,841 sqft
Beds
4 Beds
Baths
1 Bath
Lot Size
71.31 ac
Home Size
N/A
Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
-
Lot Size27,443 sqft
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size5.03 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size5.51 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size4,400 sqft
Home Size908 sqft
Beds3 Beds
Baths1 Bath
-
Lot Size16.00 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size20.22 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size3.69 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size5,716 sqft
Home Size1,728 sqft
Beds4 Beds
Baths2 Baths
-
Lot Size1.33 ac
Home Size738 sqft
Beds3 Beds
Baths2 Baths
-
Lot Size36,225 sqft
Home Size1,229 sqft
Beds3 Beds
Baths1 Bath
-
Lot Size3.29 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size44.50 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size50.50 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size8.07 ac
Home Size1,841 sqft
Beds4 Beds
Baths1 Bath
-
Lot Size54.50 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size71.31 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size95.03 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size119.00 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A
-
Lot Size3.17 ac
Home SizeN/A
BedsN/A
BathsN/A