3741 Mayfair Lane, Cambridge, OH 43725 (MLS # 5203307)

Request More Info

No property photo available

Price	$175,000
Status	Active
Beds	3
Baths	2 Baths
Home size	1,232 sqft
Lot Size	1.99 ac
Days on Market	3

Affordable country home on 1.99 acres with room to build out a small homestead. The acreage offers usable ground, scenic views, and space for a garden, small livestock, or hobby farming. Access is via a shared Easement. The home features 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, with 1,040 square feet of living space, wood floors, and a functional layout. A 192 sq ft sunroom adds extra usable space. Electric baseboard heat, no central A/C, fireplace is currently inoperable, city water, and septic system. Full basement for storage and a 1-car garage. Located just 5 minutes from New Concord and 10 minutes from

Property Type(s): Single Family

Last Updated	4/21/2026	Year Built	1973
Garage Spaces	1.0	County	Guernsey

Additional Details

AIR	None
BASEMENT	Full, Yes
CONSTRUCTION	Vinyl Siding
GARAGE	Yes
HEAT	Baseboard
LOT	1.99 acre(s)
PARKING	Attached, Garage
SEWER	Septic Tank
STORIES	1
STYLE	Ranch
TAXES	1626
WATER	Public

Location

Contact us about this Property

First Name
Last Name
Phone Number
Email Address
Schedule a Showing?	/
Comments


We respect your online privacy and will never spam you. By submitting this form with your telephone number you are consenting for Ben Schafer to contact you even if your name is on a Federal or State "Do not call List".

Listing provided by: Tristden M Bauer | 614-745-5520, Mossy Oak Properties Bauer Realty & Auctions, LLC, tbauer@mossyoakproperties.com, 614-745-5520

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of NEOHREX. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Ben Schafer Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).

Listing information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed.

Data Last Updated: 4/22/26 5:59 PM PDT

This IDX solution is (c) Diverse Solutions 2026.

Search for your next home

Latest Real Estate

409 East Street
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 409 East Street, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5203152)

$0

Lot Size

2,109 sqft

Home Size

1,456 sqft

Beds

2 Beds

Baths

1 Bath

0 Clem Garvin Road
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 0 Clem Garvin Road, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5195956)

$1

Lot Size

130.80 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

0 Tract 14 CR 7 Rear
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 0 Tract 14 CR 7 Rear, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5194455)

$1

Lot Size

128.00 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

612 West Street #Suite 7
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 612 West Street #Suite 7, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 4476348)

$450

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

612 West Street #Suite 6
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 612 West Street #Suite 6, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 4476345)

$500

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

612 West Street #Suite 5
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 612 West Street #Suite 5, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 4476342)

$500

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

612 West Street #Suite 4
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 612 West Street #Suite 4, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 4476337)

$500

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

612 West Street #Suite 3
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 612 West Street #Suite 3, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 4476334)

$500

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

802 Fairground Street
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 802 Fairground Street, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5175588)

$29,900

Lot Size

8,712 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

608 west Street
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 608 west Street, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5106723)

$49,900

Lot Size

6,665 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

SR 215
Caldwell, OH

Photo of SR 215, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5170624)

$60,000

Lot Size

5.03 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

512 North Street
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 512 North Street, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5194213)

$74,900

Lot Size

2,527 sqft

Home Size

1,870 sqft

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

834 North Street
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 834 North Street, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5183971)

$83,000

Lot Size

5,750 sqft

Home Size

1,208 sqft

Beds

3 Beds

Baths

1 Bath

616 Miller Street
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 616 Miller Street, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5171845)

$85,000

Lot Size

2,501 sqft

Home Size

1,313 sqft

Beds

3 Beds

Baths

1 Bath

606 West Street
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 606 West Street, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5195718)

$124,000

Lot Size

1,917 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

2 Beds

Baths

2 Baths

519 North Street
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 519 North Street, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5195818)

$169,000

Lot Size

6,670 sqft

Home Size

1,856 sqft

Beds

4 Beds

Baths

2 Baths

44250 Fairground Road
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 44250 Fairground Road, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5120764)

$199,900

Lot Size

3.29 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

16895 Bronze Heights Lane
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 16895 Bronze Heights Lane, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5176477)

$229,900

Lot Size

23,262 sqft

Home Size

3,408 sqft

Beds

3 Beds

Baths

2 Baths

49197 John Tomcho Road
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 49197 John Tomcho Road, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5117872)

$320,000

Lot Size

25,483 sqft

Home Size

2,376 sqft

Beds

5 Beds

Baths

3 Baths

Parry Hollow
Caldwell, OH

Photo of Parry Hollow, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5196299)

$513,300

Lot Size

102.66 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

8902 N State Route 78
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 8902 N State Route 78, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5200278)

$589,000

Lot Size

15.00 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

2 Beds

Baths

2 Baths

17030 McConnellsville Road
Caldwell, OH

Photo of 17030 McConnellsville Road, Caldwell, OH 43724 (MLS # 5178266)

$1,950,000

Lot Size

3.17 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

409 East Street
Caldwell, OH

$0

Lot Size

2,109 sqft

Home Size

1,456 sqft

Beds

2 Beds

Baths

1 Bath
0 Clem Garvin Road
Caldwell, OH

$1

Lot Size

130.80 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
0 Tract 14 CR 7 Rear
Caldwell, OH

$1

Lot Size

128.00 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
612 West Street #Suite 7
Caldwell, OH

$450

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
612 West Street #Suite 6
Caldwell, OH

$500

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
612 West Street #Suite 5
Caldwell, OH

$500

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
612 West Street #Suite 4
Caldwell, OH

$500

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
612 West Street #Suite 3
Caldwell, OH

$500

Lot Size

4,356 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
802 Fairground Street
Caldwell, OH

$29,900

Lot Size

8,712 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
608 west Street
Caldwell, OH

$49,900

Lot Size

6,665 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
SR 215
Caldwell, OH

$60,000

Lot Size

5.03 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
512 North Street
Caldwell, OH

$74,900

Lot Size

2,527 sqft

Home Size

1,870 sqft

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
834 North Street
Caldwell, OH

$83,000

Lot Size

5,750 sqft

Home Size

1,208 sqft

Beds

3 Beds

Baths

1 Bath
616 Miller Street
Caldwell, OH

$85,000

Lot Size

2,501 sqft

Home Size

1,313 sqft

Beds

3 Beds

Baths

1 Bath
606 West Street
Caldwell, OH

$124,000

Lot Size

1,917 sqft

Home Size

N/A

Beds

2 Beds

Baths

2 Baths
519 North Street
Caldwell, OH

$169,000

Lot Size

6,670 sqft

Home Size

1,856 sqft

Beds

4 Beds

Baths

2 Baths
44250 Fairground Road
Caldwell, OH

$199,900

Lot Size

3.29 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
16895 Bronze Heights Lane
Caldwell, OH

$229,900

Lot Size

23,262 sqft

Home Size

3,408 sqft

Beds

3 Beds

Baths

2 Baths
49197 John Tomcho Road
Caldwell, OH

$320,000

Lot Size

25,483 sqft

Home Size

2,376 sqft

Beds

5 Beds

Baths

3 Baths
Parry Hollow
Caldwell, OH

$513,300

Lot Size

102.66 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A
8902 N State Route 78
Caldwell, OH

$589,000

Lot Size

15.00 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

2 Beds

Baths

2 Baths
17030 McConnellsville Road
Caldwell, OH

$1,950,000

Lot Size

3.17 ac

Home Size

N/A

Beds

N/A

Baths

N/A

Previous Next